Lessons from the Tai Po Fire for Corporate Philanthropy Strategy

On 26 November 2025, an unprecedented fire at Wang Fuk Court in Tai Po drew widespread attention from all sectors of society. In addition to the full-scale efforts of various government departments, including the Fire Services Department, and social welfare agencies, enterprises quickly stepped in as another important force in disaster relief.


Wang Miao and Professor Shipeng Yan

7 October 2026

On 26 November 2025, an unprecedented fire at Wang Fuk Court in Tai Po drew widespread attention from all sectors of society. In addition to the full-scale efforts of various government departments, including the Fire Services Department, and social welfare agencies, enterprises quickly stepped in as another important force in disaster relief. It was reported that, as of 15 December 2025, more than 320 A-share-listed and Hong Kong-listed enterprises had worked with the Government and non-profit organizations to donate for disaster relief, with contributions totalling approximately HK$3 billion, thereby providing solid material support for reconstruction efforts.

As market entities with substantial resources and professional capabilities, what role do enterprises play in post-disaster reconstruction?

From donating money to contributing capabilities

Corporate philanthropy has long been regarded as an add-on activity following profit distribution: enterprises first generate profits and then return a portion of them to society. In 1991, management scholar Archie B. Carroll proposed the concept of the “pyramid of corporate social responsibility”, placing philanthropy at the apex of the pyramid and emphasizing its voluntary nature (see Note 1). Since then, discussions of corporate philanthropy have gradually shifted from “whether to donate” to “how to create greater social value”. In 2002, Michael E. Porter and Mark R. Kramer published an article in the Harvard Business Review, arguing that enterprises should align their philanthropic investments with their distinctive capabilities and competitive context, thereby making corporate expertise a means of giving back to society (see Note 2).

Enterprises as key participants in disaster relief

During the No. 5 alarm fire, enterprises’ actions vividly illustrated this paradigm shift in social responsibility. According to my research, 140 enterprises deployed capabilities closely related to their core businesses for disaster relief, accounting for nearly half of the enterprises involved in the relief effort. Spanning around eight industries, these companies mobilized resources that were highly diverse and specialized. On the day after the tragic fire, SF Express swiftly opened all 146 of its service points across Hong Kong to transport relief supplies free of charge, putting its logistics network directly to use in disaster relief (see Note 3). In addition to donating HK$20 million, Sun Hung Kai Properties opened 160 transitional housing units to provide temporary accommodation for affected residents (see Note 4). Three hotels under Guangdong Holdings Limited also voluntarily made guest rooms available, accommodating more than 178 stays by affected residents, while also allocating supplies including 1,000 cartons of milk and 500 chairs with backrests (see Note 5).

The government and specialized social organizations have traditionally been the principal actors in disaster relief, while enterprises have remained on the periphery of the conventional relief system, participating mainly through donations of funds and essential supplies. With the deepening division of labour in the modern economy, however, an increasing number of key urban resources and specialized capabilities have taken root within enterprises. As a result, enterprises are gradually shifting from being donors to becoming central nodes in the disaster relief system, forming a complementary relationship with traditional charitable actors. Studies have shown that, in sudden disasters, the participation of local enterprises is conducive to relief efforts. When corporate assistance accounts for a relatively high proportion of relief work, the overall social recovery of disaster-affected areas over the following decade is significantly better than that of areas with lower levels of corporate participation, demonstrating the distinctive advantages of corporate involvement in disaster relief (see Note 6). My preliminary analysis finds that this difference in capabilities is also reflected in capital markets: enterprises that specifically explain in their announcements how they deploy their specialized capabilities subsequently receive more positive stock market reactions.

Institutionalization potential under sudden pressure

Although many enterprises possess unique and substantial disaster relief resources, not all of them have a disaster response mechanism capable of responding in a timely manner. According to my figures, the average response time of enterprises after the fire was 3.6 days, with more than half able to take swift action within two days. Still, their responses varied significantly. Some enterprises were able to complete decision-making, mobilize personnel, and deliver resources to the disaster-affected areas within a few hours, while others were slow to reach internal consensus or take action.

This difference reflects whether an enterprise has a clear emergency authorization mechanism, whether its key resources can be deployed across departments, and whether different business units have prior experience in coordination. Efficient disaster relief measures cannot be improvised at the last minute; they must be built on organizational routines and learning mechanisms accumulated over time through ongoing business operations.

China Merchants Group is exemplary in this regard. In 2014, to meet the emergency logistics needs of disaster response, the Group established the “Relief Supplies Express” logistics platform. Leveraging the strength of its logistics and transportation business network, it has worked closely with relief organizations in disaster-affected areas and has responded on multiple occasions to public emergency transportation needs, including during the Sichuan earthquake, urban flooding, and COVID-19 prevention and control. Drawing on its extensive practical experience, “Relief Supplies Express” has developed a mature disaster relief mechanism. During the Tai Po fire, the programme enabled China Merchants Group to become one of the fastest-responding enterprises, opening up a cross-border channel for transporting supplies from the Mainland to Hong Kong with exceptional efficiency (see Note 7).

An enterprise’s rescue capabilities in sudden disasters fully reveal the institutionalized capabilities it has developed over the long term. Such capabilities may normally be highly latent: they may not necessarily be explicitly reflected in corporate social responsibility investments, and they are also difficult to identify from environmental, social, and governance reports. Once a crisis occurs, however, the long-accumulated differences among organizations quickly become apparent. Therefore, an enterprise’s actions are merely a projection of its enduring capabilities under extreme circumstances, and the boundaries of those capabilities have largely been defined by the structure of its day-to-day operations.

How enterprises contribute to urban resilience

The fire at Wang Fuk Court in Tai Po clearly demonstrates the potential of enterprises to transform commercial assets into public value. To solidify this potential into stable and sustainable urban resilience, it is essential to continuously improve enterprises’ internal capability-building and external collaboration mechanisms.

First, enterprises should have a stable resource base. My research finds that enterprises with more ample operating cash flow, stronger profitability, and lower leverage are more likely to make decisions to provide relief earlier. Therefore, the financial flexibility and resource reserves developed through day-to-day operations directly affect the scope for action available to companies during a crisis. Second, enterprises should identify in advance their own mobilization capabilities in public crises, and review and update this assessment as their businesses change. By doing so, they can form clear expectations for action before a crisis occurs and reduce the time costs of reassessing and reallocating resources after a disaster. Finally, enterprises should establish regularized coordination channels with the government and social organizations to reduce resource misallocation, duplicative investment, and mismatches between supply and demand, thereby ensuring that corporate resources are precisely aligned with frontline needs.

Such a collaborative model has already begun to take shape. In 2026, the Hong Kong Council of Social Service established the Tai Po Fire Resource Matching Platform to promote resource integration, with plans to further connect supply chain, logistics, and business partners (see Note 8). This post-fire exploration can also serve as a starting point for institutional preparedness.

The shift from “donating money” to “contributing capabilities” changes not only the practice of corporate social responsibility, but also the general logic by which a city responds to risk. How to enable the commercial capabilities dispersed throughout the market to be transformed rapidly and systematically into public emergency response capabilities when a crisis occurs may be the lesson most worthy of deep reflection and practice by Hong Kong after the disaster.

Note 1: https://doi.org/10.1016/0007-6813(91)90005-G

Note 2:https://hbr.org/2002/12/the-competitive-advantage-of-corporate-philanthropy

Note 3:https://finance.sina.com.cn/chanjing/gsnews/2025-11-27/doc-infyvthc0830274.shtml

Note 4:https://mp.weixin.qq.com/s/GZhRGcrwvXm-FNg73vE6-g

Note 5:https://www.wenweipo.com/a/202512/06/AP69344306e4b019322230b647.html

Note 6:https://doi.org/10.5465/amj.2015.0765

Note 7:https://www.cmcf.org.cn/content/2160

Note 8:https://www.hkcss.org.hk/hkcss-support-for-tai-po-fire-incident/?lang=en

Translation

大埔火災對企業慈善戰略的啟示

2025年11月26日,大埔宏福苑一場空前大火引起了社會各界的高度關注。除了包括消防處的各政府部門和社會福利機構全力投入救援外,企業作為另一股重要救災力量,同時迅速進場。截至12月15日,據報共有320多家A股、港股上市公司聯合政府、非牟利機構捐款賑災,總額約達30億元,為重建工作提供了堅實的物質支撐。

企業作為掌握大量資源與專業能力的市場主體,在災後重建中扮演何種角色?

從捐錢到捐能力

長期以來,企業慈善被視為利潤分配後的一種附加動作:企業先行創造利潤,再將其中一部分回饋社會。1991年,管理學家卡羅爾(Archie B. Carroll)提出「企業社會責任金字塔」(pyramid of corporate social responsibility)的概念,將慈善置於塔尖,強調其自願性【註1】。其後,企業慈善的討論逐漸從「應否捐贈」轉向「如何創造更大的社會價值」。2002年,波特(Michael E. Porter)與克雷默(Mark R. Kramer)在《哈佛商業評論》撰文,主張企業應當把慈善投入與自身的獨特能力和競爭環境結合起來,讓企業的專長成為其回饋社會的方式【註2】。

企業成為救災的重要參與者

是次5級大火之中,企業的表現深刻詮釋了這一社會責任的範式轉移。根據筆者的研究,有140家企業調用了與自身核心業務高度相關的能力進行救災,幾近參與救援企業的半數。這些企業橫跨約8個行業,所投入的資源呈現高度多樣化與專業化。火災慘劇第二天,順豐迅速開放全港146個順豐站,免費運送救援物資,其物流網路直接用於賑災【註3】。地產商新鴻基在捐款2000萬港元之餘,更開放160間過渡性住宅,以供災民暫住【註4】。粵海集團旗下3家酒店亦主動開放客房,入住災民超過178人次,同時調配1000箱牛奶、500張靠背椅等物資【註5】。

政府和專業社會組織向來是災害救援的主體,而企業則處於傳統救援體系的周邊,以捐助款項和必要物資等方式參與。隨着現代經濟分工不斷深化,城市中愈來愈多關鍵資源和專業能力扎根於企業內部,企業逐漸從捐贈者變成救災體系中的核心節點,並與傳統慈善主體形成能力互補。有研究表明,在突發災難中,當地企業參與有利於救援工作,當企業援助佔比較高時,受災地區在隨後10年的整體社會恢復表現明顯優於企業參與較少的地區,體現出企業參與救災的獨特優勢【註6】。筆者的初步分析發現,這種能力差異同樣反映於資本市場:在公告中具體說明如何運用自身專業能力的企業,其後股市反應更為正面。

突發壓力下的制度化潛能

事實上,很多企業都擁有獨特而豐富的救災資源,但不是所有企業都具備及時回應的救災體系。據筆者統計,火災發生後企業的平均回應時間為3.6天,其中超過半數能在兩天之內迅速行動。然而有關行動存在顯著差異,部分企業足以在數小時內完成決策、調動人員,並把資源送往災區,有些卻遲遲未能在內部達成共識或採取行動。

這種差異反映出企業是否存在清晰的緊急授權機制,關鍵資源能否跨部門調用,不同業務單元之間又是否具有協同經驗。高效的救災行動不能急來抱佛腳,必須基於經營過程中日積月累的組織慣例和學習機制。

招商局集團在這方面堪稱典範。2014年,為應對災害應急物流需求,該局成立「災急送」物流平台。借助物流運輸的業務網路優勢,其與受災區救援機構密切協作,先後在四川地震、城市洪澇、新冠疫情防控中多次響應社會應急運輸需求。基於豐富的實踐經驗,「災急送」已形成成熟的災害救援機制,在大埔火災中成為回應速度最快的企業之一,以極高效率打通內地至香港的跨境物資運輸通道【註7】。

企業在突發災難中的救援能力,直接展示其長期形成的制度化能力。這類能力平時或屬高度隱性,未必明確顯現為企業社會責任投入,也很難從環境、社會及管治(ESG)報告中直接識別;一旦危機發生,組織之間長期積累的差異便會迅速顯現。因此,企業的行動只是其長期能力在極端情境下的投射,而其能力邊界大致上已由日常運營結構所限定。

企業如何提升城市韌性

大埔宏福苑大火充分證明,企業具備將商業資產轉化為公共價值的潛力。要使這種潛力沉澱為穩定、可持續的城市韌性,務須不斷完善企業內部的能力建設與外部的協作機制。

首先,企業應具備穩定的資源基礎。筆者的研究發現,企業經營性現金流愈充裕、盈利能力愈強、槓桿水平愈低,就愈可能更早作出救助決策。因此,日常經營形成的財務彈性與資源儲備,會直接影響企業在危機中的行動空間。其次,企業應提前識別自身在公共危機中的動員能力,並隨業務變化評估更新,從而在危機發生前形成清晰的行動預期,減少災後重新判斷和配置資源的時間成本。最後,應與政府、社會組織建構常態化的協作介面,減少資源錯配、重複投入與供需脫節,使企業資源精準對接前線需求。

這種協同模式無疑已見雛形。2026年,香港社會服務聯會建立「大埔火災資源配對平台」,推動資源整合,並計劃進一步連接供應鏈、物流及商業夥伴【註8】。火災過後的探索,也可成為制度上未雨綢繆的起點。

從「捐錢」邁向「捐能力」,改變的是企業社會責任實踐的方式,也是城市應對風險的普遍邏輯。如何讓分散在市場中的商業能力,在危機來臨時能夠迅速、有序地轉化為公共應急能力,也許是災後最值得香港深思躬行的一課。

註1:https://doi.org/10.1016/0007-6813(91)90005-G

註2:https://hbr.org/2002/12/the-competitive-advantage-of-corporate-philanthropy

註3:https://finance.sina.com.cn/chanjing/gsnews/2025-11-27/doc-infyvthc0830274.shtml

註4:https://mp.weixin.qq.com/s/GZhRGcrwvXm-FNg73vE6-g

註5:https://www.wenweipo.com/a/202512/06/AP69344306e4b019322230b647.html

註6:https://doi.org/10.5465/amj.2015.0765

註7:https://www.cmcf.org.cn/content/2160

註8:https://www.hkcss.org.hk/hkcss-support-for-tai-po-fire-incident/?lang=en

王淼
武漢大學學生

顏示硼教授
港大經管學院管理及商業策略助理教授

(本文同時於二零二六年十月七日載於《信報》「龍虎山下」專欄)