Exploring ESG Practices in the Ningxia Wine Industry

Ningxia has emerged as a key wine production region in China, contributing nearly half of the country’s total output. The wineries here not only stimulate local economic growth but also lead in Environmental, Social, and Governance (ESG) initiatives, promoting sustainable agriculture, biodiversity, and cultural preservation.


Olivia Li, Yanlong Zhang, Shipeng Yan: Ningxia is an important hub for Chinese wines. Various wineries have accelerated their development by implementing environmental, social, and governance (ESG) initiatives. These moves enhance competitiveness while also promoting a more sustainable economy.

With its unique climate and soil conditions, the Donglu region in Ningxia’s Helan Mountains has emerged as China’s largest wine-producing area. By the end of 2023, the Ningxia region already had 130 wineries, with more than 110 new wineries under construction. Wine-friendly grapes are planted on more than 600,000 acres, almost 40% of China’s total area dedicated to the crops. Annual wine production reached 140 million bottles, almost half of the country’s total volume. Since 2011, grape wines from the Donglu region have received several international awards, and are now sold to over 40 countries and regions, further strengthening the competitiveness of Chinese wines in the international market (Note 1).

 Ningxia’s wine industry has developed rapidly, not only boosting local economic growth but also actively promoting sustainable agricultural practices, biodiversity protection, low-carbon green development, and cultural preservation. The region has become a pioneer in promoting ESG practices in China’s wine industry, making positive research and contributions to the industry’s sustainable development.

Responsible Consumption and Production

Combating climate change is an important issue for the wine industry (Note 2). Many of the region’s wineries have been pushing for greener, low-carbon, and sustainable development. For example, Xige Estate, a winery in Qingtongxia and in the foothills of the Helan Mountains, has taken the initiative to produce paper packaging, cartons and coasters from grape skin, pulp and vine. According to Zhao Qian who heads public affairs at Xige Estate, each tonne of recycled paper they use contains 30% grape skin and pulp. Given that one tonne of the environmentally friendly paper saves approximately 1.2 cubic metres of timber resources, the winery can reduce an estimated 50 cubic metres of wood per year, a significant decrease in wood use.

Xige Estate has also replaced glass bottles with aluminium cans in its “Little Drinks” range. The cans are lighter than glass containers, which lead to lower carbon emissions during transport. The Little Drinks range also features packing materials composed entirely of grape skin and pulp, fully using available resources.


Photo 1: Xige Estate’s red wine packaged in paper made from grape waste


Photo 2: Solar panels at Xige Estate

Environmental Symbiosis

The Donglu region in the Helan Mountains sits in an isolated desert with a fragile ecosystem. To address this, some wineries have adopted ecological restoration initiatives, measures to protect biodiversity, and ways to regenerate agriculture. All of these steps aim at lowering the environmental impact from wine production.

From the start, at Chandon China, a winery in the LVMH portfolio, sustainability has firmly remained at its core. The winery has championed the concept of “Living Soils, Living Together,” placing a strong emphasis on healthy soil and rich biodiversity as the basis of producing quality wine. Chandon China follows the principles of regenerative agriculture to enhance soil health and enrich biodiversity. The winery has also taken steps to slash greenhouse gas emissions. Such as with reduced mechanised farming, adopting precision irrigation, and growing cover crops in the mid-rows and cover crops under vines. By creating habitats for bees and planting diverse plants, Chandon China has effectively supported biodiversity growth. The Company’s China’s Estate Director Su Long said that in 2021 they launched a third-party biodiversity audit. The plan is to increase the number of species at the premises by 15-20% every year.


Picture 3: Cover crops in the mid-rows at Chandon China’s vineyard


Picture 4: A bee skep at Chandon China’s vineyard

Yuanshi Vineyard is a strong example of ecological restoration in production areas. They have given new life to an abandoned sand-mining pit, which is now an integrated vineyard that also offers ecotourism and cultural experiences. Through afforestation and restoring its water system, the winery has built a vineyard spanning 2,000 acres. It is now a unique ecosystem for more than 300 species and 2 million plants. Ecological restoration has notably enhanced the area’s biodiversity (Note 3).


Picture 5: Yuanshi Vineyard, transformed from a sand mine


Picture 6: Ecological restoration at Yuanshi Vineyard

Domaine Charme, a progressive winery in the Jinshan production district, has followed natural farming methods. It has avoided mechanised farming and preserved the existing soil layer to maintain its natural state. Owner Zhang Pai and his team manually cleared rocks to protect the humus layer, as well as planted windbreaks as barriers against natural disasters. Through nitrogen fixation and raising geese for weeding purposes, the winery has also avoided using chemical fertilisers and herbicides. These measures not only help sustain soil fertility and maintain an ecological balance, but they also enhance biodiversity.


Picture 7: Domaine Charme


Picture 8: Domaine Charme’s natural farming methods

Community Development

The ability to discover local specialties, culture and traditions is a crucial starting point for wineries and companies keen to build a unique product identity and strengthen community engagement. For example, as one of China’s High and New Technology Enterprises (HNTE), Jade Vineyard has always been devoted to planting technology. Its plantation was the first to be recognised as a high standard example by China’s National Open Development Comprehensive Pilot Zone for Grape and Wine Industry. The winery’s products have received numerous awards, both at home and abroad.

While pursuing quality wine, Jade Vineyard also built a library and a café, using these venues as cultural spaces for regularly holding painting and photography exhibitions. These events have led to collaborations with Chinese and overseas artists to provide unique art and cultural experiences for visitors. The winery is an eager and active participant in the promotion of Helan Mountains’ culture. One of the ways has been by encouraging local employees and residents to study local folk art. These practices protect and preserve Ningxia’s local culture. They also enhance the community’s cultural health.


Picture 9: An exhibition at Jade Vineyard


Picture 10: Exterior of Jade Vineyard

Yuanshi Vineyard has worked with the Yinchuan Municipal Government to build a cultural and sports park, where the public can enjoy a safe and inclusive green public space. The vineyard has also combined ecological restoration with industry research and development to achieve a harmonious balance between industry and ecology. The winery welcomes 200,000 visitors every year, and with its ecotourism revenue surpassing 20 million yuan, it has become a new driving force for local economic growth (Note 4). Yunashi Vineyard firmly believes that ecological sustainable development is the core to the long-term prosperity and growth of the wine industry.

The authors also discovered from their research that most of the wineries are still faced with several challenges when it comes to integrating ESG concepts into their operational and management systems. These challenges come in the form of resource allocation, technological advancements, staff training, and reshaping culture. Even if the region is still in the early stages of figuring out how best to achieve sustainable development while maintaining high-quality growth, the wineries that have taken the lead have set great examples for the wine industry. These successful examples undoubtedly provide their peers with valuable experience and insight. They continue to inspire the industry in spearheading the move towards a more environmentally friendly, harmonious and efficient development model.

The co-authors of this article are Olivia Li Yining, MBA graduate of Peking University Guanghua School of Management, Founder and CEO of Ecoliv ESG; Yanlong Zhang, Associate Professor at Peking University Guanghua School of Management; Shipeng Yan, Associate Professor, Management and Strategy at HKU Business School.

Professor Shipeng YAN
Associate Professor in Management and Strategy

Note 1:http://nx.people.com.cn/n2/2024/0813/c192150-40942550.html

Note 2:https://www.reuters.com/business/sustainable-business/hard-hit-by-climate-change-winemakers-turn-sustainability-ride-storms-2022-09-14/

Note 3:https://www.caghp.org.cn/detail/3475.html

Note 4:https://www.caghp.org.cn/detail/3475.html

Translation

探究寧夏葡萄酒産業的ESG實踐


寧夏賀蘭山東麓地區,依托其獨特的氣候和土壤條件,近年來成爲中國最大的連片酒莊葡萄酒産區。截至2023年底,寧夏産區已建成130家酒莊,另外正興建的酒莊亦有110多家。釀酒葡萄種植面積超過60萬畝,占全國近40%;年産葡萄酒達1.4億瓶,占國産酒莊酒釀造總量的近半。2011年以來,賀蘭山東麓的葡萄酒在國際大賽中屢獲殊榮,遠銷至40多個國家和地區,進一步增强中國葡萄酒在國際市場的競爭力【註1】

寧夏葡萄酒行業快速發展,除帶動當地經濟發展外,亦通過積極推廣可持續農業實踐、生物多樣性保護、低碳綠色發展以及在地文化保護,成爲中國葡萄酒行業中推動環境、社會及管治(Environmental, Social and Governance,簡稱ESG)實踐的先鋒,爲行業可持續發展作出積極貢獻和探索。

負責任消費和生産


應對氣候變化是葡萄酒行業的一個重要議題【註2】。産區許多酒莊已經積極推進綠色、低碳、循環發展。例如,位于青銅峽的西鴿酒莊率先將釀酒過程中産生的葡萄皮渣及葡萄藤轉化爲再生紙漿,幷用于酒瓶包裝盒、紙箱及紙杯墊等包裝上。西鴿酒莊公共事務負責人趙倩表示,酒莊采用的環保紙每噸含有30%的皮渣成分,生産1噸環保紙可節約1.2立方米的木材資源。據此推算,酒莊每年可减少約50立方米的木材使用量,顯著降低資源消耗。此外,西鴿推出的“小酌”系列産品,用創新的易拉罐包裝取代了傳統的玻璃瓶。相較于玻璃瓶,易拉罐的重量更輕,在運輸過程中大幅减少碳排放。“小酌”系列的包裝材料也完全由葡萄皮渣和回收材料製成,全方位實現資源循環利用。


圖 1西鴿酒莊正牌“藤上藤”皮渣包瓶紙


圖 2西鴿酒莊綠化及太陽能光伏板

環境共生


賀蘭山東麓的荒漠地帶,生態系統脆弱。爲此,一些酒莊通過實施生態修復工程、保護生物多樣性、推廣再生農業等措施,减輕對環境的不利影響。在這方面,LVMH集團旗下的夏桐酒莊從建莊早期便開始强調可持續發展理念。酒莊提出“由壤而生,永續共生”,主張健康的土壤和豐富的生物多樣性是釀造優質葡萄酒的基礎。爲此,夏桐遵循再生農業原則,提高土壤健康、增强生物多樣性;同時减少機械耕作、采用精准節水灌溉技術、行間生草行下覆蓋等一系列减少溫室氣體排放的措施。夏桐通過創建蜜蜂栖息地和種植多樣化的植物,有效促進了生物多樣性的增長。夏桐酒莊總經理蘇龍表示,夏桐于2021年啓動了第三方生物多樣性審計,幷計劃在此基礎上設置目標,每年增加園區內15%到20%的物種數量。


圖 3夏桐酒莊葡萄園行間生草


圖 4夏桐酒葡萄園中的蜂箱

源石酒莊是産區生態修復的典範,他們將一片廢弃的采砂坑改造爲集葡萄種植、生態旅游和文化體驗于一體的綜合酒莊。酒莊通過植樹造林和水系修復工程,建立了2,000畝葡萄園,幷打造出一個包含超過300多種、200萬株植物的獨特生態系統,通過生態修復顯著增强了該地區的生物多樣性【註3】


圖表 5礦坑改造而成的源石酒莊


圖表 6源石酒莊生態修復

而金山産區的新銳酒莊——夏木酒莊,則遵循自然農法原則,避免機械化耕作,保留原始土壤層,維護土壤的自然結構。莊主張湃及其團隊通過人工清理石塊,保護腐殖土層,幷利用防風林來抵禦自然灾害。同時,透過豆類植物固氮和養鵝除草,有效避免使用化肥和除草劑,保持土壤的天然肥力與生態平衡,也提升了園內的生物多樣性。


圖表 7夏木酒莊


圖表 8夏木酒莊自然農法

社區發展


發掘當地風土特色和文化傳統是酒莊和葡萄酒企業打造獨特産品認同、增强社區鏈接的重要抓手。例如,作爲國家高新技術企業的嘉地酒園,一直在種植技術方面堅持投入,其種植園獲得第一批國家葡萄與葡萄酒産業開放發展綜合實驗區高標準示範園稱號。其産品在國內外也屢獲大獎。在追求高品質葡萄酒的同時,嘉地酒園在酒莊開闢了圖書館、咖啡廳等公共文化空間定期舉辦繪畫和攝影展覽,吸引中國及海外藝術家合作,爲游客提供融合藝術與文化的獨特體驗。此外,酒莊鼓勵本地員工和居民研習寧夏小曲等地方特色曲藝,銳意成爲賀蘭山文化傳播的參與者。這些做法保護和傳承了寧夏本地文化,同時極大提升了當地社區的文化活力。


圖 9嘉地酒園藝術展


圖 10嘉地酒園外觀

源石酒莊與銀川市政府合作打造文化運動公園,爲市民提供了安全、包容的綠色公共空間。此外,源石酒莊的生態修復與産業開發相結合,實現産業與生態的和諧共生。酒莊年均接待游客20萬人次,生態旅游收入突破2,000萬元,成爲推動當地經濟增長的新動力【註4】。源石酒莊深信,生態的可持續發展是葡萄酒産業長期繁榮發展的核心。

筆者在調研中也看到,對于大多數酒莊企業而言,將ESG理念整合到經營和管理的體系中仍舊面臨著諸多挑戰,包括資源分配、技術革新、員工培訓及文化重塑等。儘管産區在可持續發展的征途上仍處于摸索前行的初級階段,但那些勇于擔當、先行先試的酒莊,通過不懈努力與創新實踐,已然爲整個葡萄酒行業樹立了可持續與高質量發展的典範。這些成功案例,無疑爲同行提供了寶貴的經驗與啓示,激勵著整個行業向著更加環保、和諧與高效的發展模式邁進。

註1:http://nx.people.com.cn/n2/2024/0813/c192150-40942550.html

註2:https://www.reuters.com/business/sustainable-business/hard-hit-by-climate-change-winemakers-turn-sustainability-ride-storms-2022-09-14/

註3:https://www.caghp.org.cn/detail/3475.html

註4:https://www.caghp.org.cn/detail/3475.html

顔示硼教授
港大經管學院管理及商業策略助理教授

張閆龍教授
北京大學光華管理學院副教授

厲以寧女士
北京大學光華管理學院MBA畢業生、歐勵蔚Ecoliv ESG諮詢創始人兼CEO

(本文同時于二零二四年十一月二十八日載于《FT中文網》「明德商論」專欄)