Analyzing Hong Kong’s Overall Economic Situation with Data – Part Two

How can we leverage voluminous and critical data to gain insights into Hong Kong’s macro-economic landscape? In today’s data-driven world, diverse stakeholders often arrive at vastly different conclusions by examining various datasets through unique lenses and methodologies. However, Dr. Chi Pui Ho advocates that to truly comprehend the overall economic trends, we should employ economic…


Over the past few decades, thanks to its prime geographical location, open access to international trade and investment, robust banking sector, sound regulatory framework, and vibrant stock market, Hong Kong has facilitated the demand for local financial services from investors and foreign companies. The city has thus successfully evolved into an international financial centre.

Pressing need for financial adjustments amid geopolitical challenges

Under the influence of the Linked Exchange Rate System, Hong Kong’s money supply and interest rate movements mostly mirror the US Federal Reserve’s monetary policy decisions (see Figure 1).

Figure 1 Hong Kong monetary base and money supplies M1, M2, M3 (HK$ in trillions)

In other words, to maintain the stability of Hong Kong’s exchange rates, the SAR Government has relinquished its monetary policy autonomy. This in turn compromises its ability to address economic fluctuations and the potential risk of asset price inflation. In addition, the exchange rate of the Hong Kong dollar to other currencies will also fluctuate with the US dollar (see Figure 2), thus influencing the SAR’s import and export performance.

Figure 2 Trade-weighted exchange rate and HK-RMB exchange rate

At the turn of the 21st century, against the backdrop of globalization and its integration with the Mainland stock markets, Hong Kong continued to lure investors with the help of its status as the main gateway to China for foreign investments. This is evidenced by the rising trends of the SAR’s Hang Seng Index, stock trading volume, and market capitalization (see Figure 3).

Figure 3 Hang Seng Index

Furthermore, Hong Kong’s role as China’s window for international liquidity has also contributed to the growth in loans and advances. Hong Kong is well-equipped to provide intermediary services for Mainland enterprises seeking international financing as well as for foreign companies looking to invest in the Mainland. This has been conducive to the establishment of local lending platforms and expansion of cross-border financing activities. The sophisticated legal system and ideal regulatory environment have boosted the confidence of lenders, thus fostering an increase in loans and advances. These financial services have in turn supported the development of Hong Kong’s trade, real estate, and manufacturing industries.

Hong Kong boasts the status as an international financial centre, a strategic location as the bridge to Mainland China, and the constructive role of the Hong Kong Monetary Authority and the HKEX as a twin engine of the debt securities market. Hence, securities issuers and investors including multinational corporations and financial institutions have been flocking to the city in search of funding for business expansion, acquisitions, refinancing, etc. This has enabled Hong Kong to become a major debt issuance centre for the Southeast Asia region (see Figure 4).

Figure 4 New issuances of HKD debt securities (HK$ in billions)

It is noteworthy that recent years have seen China-US geopolitics pose a potential impact on Hong Kong’s standing as an international financial centre. The local financial market has undergone consolidation in recent years, as evidenced by the relatively steep fall of the total market value and total funds raised in the stock market. The extent of adjustment by the financial sector and the future development of Fintech and asset management will determine whether Hong Kong can reinforce and maintain its status as a leading international financial centre in Asia.

Social media-induced change in tourist spending patterns

With its historical development as a city where East meets West, its accessible transport infrastructure, and its reputation as a shopping paradise and international convention and exhibition centre, Hong Kong has been a preferred destination for leisure and business travellers from all over the world for decades, fuelling the growth of the local tourism industry. These factors are reflected in the long-term upward trend in inbound visitors, who are primarily from the Mainland (see Figures 5–6).

Figure 5 Monthly overnight visitor arrivals (in thousands)

Figure 6 Monthly same-day visitor arrivals (in thousands)

Since the 2010s, however, the emergence of social media has made it more convenient for visitors to obtain travel information about Hong Kong and to share their experiences. Fierce competition from neighbouring regions has also effected a gradual change to the travel and consumption patterns of inbound visitors.

From the mid-2010s onwards, per-capita spending of visitors to Hong Kong began to show an adverse trend mainly due to a continued decline in per-capita shopping expenditure (see Figures 7–8).

Figure 7 Per-capita overnight visitor spending (HK$)

Figure 8 Per-capita same-day visitor spending (HK$)

In the aftermath of the social incident in 2019 and the COVID-19 pandemic in 2020, which dealt a serious blow to the local tourism industry, Hong Kong has yet to see a return to the peak levels of visitor arrivals and per-capita spending recorded during the 2010s.

It is foreseeable that Hong Kong’s tourism industry is bound to face challenges, ranging from its image and positioning, the attractiveness of tourist facilities and services to global travellers, to industry policy and management structure, and the international political environment. For the industry to get back on track, a concerted effort between the government and the general public is indispensable.

Dr. Chi Pui Ho
Lecturer in Economics

(This article was also published on July 18, 2024 in the “Lung Fu Shan” column of the Hong Kong Economic Journal)

Translation
過去數十年來,香港憑藉優越的地理位置、對國際貿易和投資的開放、穩健的銀行業、健全的監管架構、活躍的股票市場,促進了投資者和外國企業對本地金融服務的需求,推動特區發展成為國際金融中心。
地緣政治挑戰 金融亟需調整

受聯繫匯率制度影響,香港的貨幣供應和利率走向大致跟隨美國聯邦儲備局的貨幣政策步伐【圖1】。



換句話說,為了維持港元匯率穩定,特區政府放棄了貨幣政策的自主權,不能以之應對經濟波動和潛在資產價格的通脹風險。另外,港元兌其他貨幣匯率亦會跟隨美元上落【圖2】,從而影響進出口表現。



二十一世紀初,香港作為中國外來投資的主要門戶,在全球一體化和跟中國內地股票市場融合的背景下,持續吸引投資者,反映在香港恒生指數、股票交易量和市值的增長趨勢【圖3】。



此外,香港作為國家流動資本的門戶,也促進了貸款和墊款的成長。香港能為尋求國際融資的內地企業、擬投資內地的外國企業提供中介服務,有助於本港建立借貸平台和擴展跨境借貸活動。香港健全的法律架構和良好的監管環境亦增加貸款機構的信心,有助於帶動貸款和墊款增長。這些金融服務支持了香港貿易、房地產和製造業等領域的發展。

香港享有國際金融中心的地位、處於中國內地門戶的戰略位置,以及金融管理局和香港交易所推動債務證券市場的效用,吸引了跨國公司和金融機構等債務證券發行人和投資者,為擴張、收購、再融資等各種目的來港尋求資金,促進香港成為東南亞地區重要的債務發行中心【圖4】。



不得不察的是,近年中美的地緣政治,或會影響香港作為國際金融中心的地位。本地金融市場近年經歷長時間整固,尤其反映在股票市場的總市值和集資總額從相對高位顯著下跌。金融業能在多大程度上作出調整、在金融科技和資產管理今後發展如何,將決定香港能否鞏固並維持其領先亞洲的國際金融中心地位。
旅客消費模式 因社媒現轉變

香港東西文化交匯的城市發展、完善的交通基建、作為購物天堂及國際會議展覽中心的美譽,在近數十年來吸引各地休閒及商務旅客絡繹而至,推動旅遊業發展。這些因素都反映在訪港旅客(主要是內地旅客)長期以來的上升趨勢【圖5及圖6】。



然而,2010年代起,社交媒體的興起使旅客更容易獲取香港旅遊資訊和分享經驗,加上鄰近地區的劇烈競爭,逐漸改變訪港旅客的旅遊和消費模式。

自2010年代中期起,訪港旅客的人均消費開始呈現下跌趨勢,其中主因在於人均購物消費的跌勢【圖7及圖8】。



2019年的社會事件和2020年的新冠肺炎疫情重創旅遊業,疫後訪港旅客不論人數或人均消費均未能回復至2010年代高峰水平。

可以預期,從旅遊業的形象和定位、旅遊設施和服務對全球旅客的吸引度、產業政策和管理架構,以至國際政治環境方面,本地旅遊業界勢將面臨重重挑戰,若要發展重拾正軌,端賴政府和市民攜手努力。

 

何志培博士
港大经管学院经济学讲师

(本文同时于二零二四年七月十八日载于《信报》「龙虎山下」专栏)