Manipulation, Panic Runs, and the Short Selling Ban

This article explores how manipulative short selling (MSS) can trigger bank runs by inducing panic among creditors, especially when informed trading and coordination frictions are high. By applying the researchers’ theoretical model, they demonstrate that short sale bans can help prevent destabilising withdrawals during crises by suppressing MSS. The findings highlight the importance of targeted…

Pingyang Gao, Xu Jiang, Jinzhi Lu,
Manipulation, panic runs, and the short selling ban,
Journal of Economic Theory; Volume 223, 2025,105939, ISSN 0022-0531
https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0022053124001455

Short selling regulation has been a longstanding topic of debate in financial markets, particularly during times of crisis. While proponents argue that short selling aids in price discovery and market efficiency, critics raise concerns about manipulative short selling practices that can destabilize markets. This paper presents a theoretical model to analyze the impact of short selling, specifically manipulative short selling (MSS), on bank runs and efficiency. The model demonstrates that MSS can emerge as an equilibrium outcome driven by uninformed speculators seeking to profit from artificially depressing stock prices. The prevalence of MSS is influenced by the level of informed trading and coordination friction among creditors. We find that short selling bans can enhance welfare by mitigating the negative effects of MSS, particularly in scenarios with high coordination frictions. We also provide policy and empirical implications.

Keywords:
Short selling regulation, Feedback effect, Strategic complementarity, Bank runs

* Learn more from the research article here:
https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0022053124001455

Translation